Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. Encyclopedia
  3. US Coins
  4. C. Bechtler (Carolina & Georgia)
  5. (1834-37) G$5 C. Bechtler RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17

(1834-37) G$5 C. Bechtler RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17

CPG Values (What is CPG?)

Grade CPG Value
VF30 $9,750.00
VF35 $10,200.00
XF40 $11,500.00
XF45 $12,000.00
AU50 $13,400.00
AU53 $14,400.00
AU55 $16,800.00
AU58 $21,000.00
MS60 $26,400.00
MS61 $31,200.00
MS62 $36,000.00
MS63 $43,200.00
VF30 CAC $11,200.00
VF35 CAC $12,000.00
XF40 CAC $13,800.00
XF45 CAC $15,000.00
AU50 CAC $17,400.00
AU53 CAC $19,200.00
AU55 CAC $21,600.00
AU58 CAC $27,600.00
MS60 CAC $36,000.00
MS61 CAC $43,200.00
MS62 CAC $52,800.00
MS63 CAC $72,000.00

Apr Data

48 records found.

    Page 1 of 1
    Description Grade Auction House Sell Price Sell Date
    (1835-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU55 PCGS. K-17, R.4. 55 HA 22,800 01/17/2025
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU50 PCGS. K-17, R.4. 50 HA 14,400 06/13/2024
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS61 PCGS. K-17, R.4. 61 HA 33,600 01/11/2024
    "1834" (1834-1837) Christopher Bechtler $5. K-17. Rarity-5. RUTHERFORD, 140.G., 20 CARATS. Plain Edge. AU-53 (PCGS). CMQ. 53 Stacks Bowers 13,200 11/21/2023
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, 140G. 20C, RUTHERFORD. XF40 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 40 HA 11,400 08/17/2023
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, VF30 PCGS. K-17, R.5. (The PCGS insert incorrectly calls this 30 HA 8,400 07/05/2023
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, VF30 PCGS. K-17, R.5. Kagin-17 is the most accessible of t 30 HA 7,800 05/24/2023
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS61 PCGS. CAC. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 48,000 05/03/2023
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS62 NGC. K-17, R.5. 62 HA 26,400 01/14/2022
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS61 NGC. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 24,000 08/18/2021
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU55 NGC. CAC. K-17, R.5. 55 HA 21,600 08/18/2021
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU58 NGC. K-17, R.5. 58 HA 15,120 01/22/2021
    (1834-37) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, XF40 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 40 HA 7,200 02/20/2020
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS63 NGC. K-17, R.5. 63 HA 22,800 01/09/2020
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS63 NGC. K-17, R.5. 63 HA 25,200 09/05/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU53 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 53 HA 9,600 04/26/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, 140 G, 20 C, AU50 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 50 HA 9,300 04/25/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, 140 G. 20 C. MS61 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 18,600 04/25/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Kagin-17, Plain Edge, R.5, MS61+ NGC. 61 HA 16,800 04/25/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, 140 G., 20 C. MS63 NGC. K-17, R.5. 63 HA 28,800 04/25/2019
    (1834-1837) $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, 140G., 20C., AU58 NGC. K-17, R.5. 58 HA 14,400 11/08/2018
    "1834" (1834-1837) Christopher Bechtler $5. K-17. Rarity-5. RUTHERFORD, 140.G., 20 CARATS. Plain Edge. MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. Gold Shield Holder. 62 Stacks Bowers 36,000 03/23/2018
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, 140G., 20C., AU50 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 50 HA 9,900 01/05/2018
    (1834-1837 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD., Plain Edge, 140G., 20C., MS60 NGC. K-17, R.5. 60 HA 14,400 01/05/2018
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, MS61 NGC. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 21,600 01/04/2018
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, XF45 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 45 HA 11,162 01/09/2017
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, AU55 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 55 HA 15,275 06/07/2015
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge, XF45 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 45 HA 9,988 06/07/2015
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge MS61 NGC. CAC. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 22,325 11/15/2014
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, Plain Edge MS63 NGC. K-17, R.5. 63 HA 35,250 03/23/2014
    Undated (1834-1837) Christopher Bechtler $5 Gold. K-17. Rarity-5. RUTHERFORD, 140.G., 20 CARATS. Plain Edge. AU-50 (NGC). 50 Stacks Bowers 11,045 11/07/2013
    Undated (1834-1837) Christopher Bechtler $5 Gold. K-17. Rarity-5. RUTHERFORD, 140.G., 20 CARATS, Plain Edge. AU-55 (NGC). 55 Stacks Bowers 16,568 08/15/2013
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge XF45 PCGS. K-17, R.5. 45 HA 8,625 08/14/2011
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 61 Ira & Larry Goldberg 17,250 01/31/2011
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 55 Stacks Bowers 14,375 11/02/2010
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge MS61 NGC. K-17, R.5. 61 HA 16,502 08/15/2010
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, Plain Edge AU55 PCGS. 55 HA 14,950 02/08/2009
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, Plain Edge--Improperly Cleaned--NCS. XF Details. 40 HA 5,750 09/21/2008
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 55 Stacks Bowers 17,538 01/07/2008
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 55 Ponterio 21,850 09/25/2007
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 45 Ponterio 9,775 09/25/2007
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, 140 G., RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge AU55 PCGS. K-17, R.5. All of the Bechtler five dollar gold 55 HA 12,650 03/17/2007
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 40 Stacks Bowers 12,650 11/07/2006
    1834 $5 C.Bechtler Five Dollar, 140 G., RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge AU50 PCGS. K-17, R.5. Collecting Bechtler five dollar pieces 50 HA 10,350 08/14/2006
    1834 $5 C.Bechtler Five Dollar, Plain Edge AU58 NGC. K-17. NGC Census: (0/0). PCGS Population (1/0). (#10091) 58 HA 12,075 02/26/2006
    (1834-37) C. Bechtler G$5 MS RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17 61 Stacks Bowers 17,250 11/30/2005
    1834 $5 C.Bechtler Five Dollar, 140 G., RUTHERFORD, Plain Edge AU58 NGC. K-17, R.5. While a couple of varieties of Bechtler 58 HA 11,500 11/05/2005
    1834 $5 C. Bechtler Five Dollar, Plain Edge AU53 PCGS. K- 53 HA 7,762 01/11/2003
      Page 1 of 1


      NNP Encyclopedia data is provided in cooperation with Whitman Brands, based on catalog data organized by the Greysheet Identification System (GSID).

      Entry Details

      PCGS Number: 10091
      Coin Date: (1834-37)
      Denomination (Short): G$5
      Denomination (Long): 5 Dollar Gold
      Variety: C. Bechtler
      Variety 2: RUTHERFORD, 140 GR, 20C, Plain Edge, K-17
      Desg: MS
      Composition: Gold
      Mintage: ~100 known
      Strike Type: Business
      Coinage Type: Pioneer & Territorial Gold
      Coinage Years: 1831-1842
      Mint Location: Carolina
      Fineness: 0.8333
      Designer: Christopher Bechtler, Sr.
      Edge: Plain
      Obverse Description: 140.G. AUGUST 1. 1834. 20. CARATS. CAROLINA GOLD
      Reverse Description: 5 DOLLARS. * C:BECHTLER.AT RUTHERFORD
      General Notes: The Kagin-17 is the most readily available Bechtler half eagle, with over 100 examples extant. It shares an obverse die with the Kagin-Transitional, Kagin-16, and Kagin-18 half eagles. The Kagin-17’s new reverse die resembles the Kagin-16 reverse but has the word DOLLARS equidistant from 5 and AT RUTHERFORD. The same reverse die is also paired with two GEORGIA GOLD obverses (K-21 and K-22). Kagin-17 is generally available graded XF/AU, and around a dozen or so mint state examples exist.
      PCGS #: 10091
      NGC ID: 2B9P
      NNP is 100% non-profit and independent // Your feedback is essential and welcome. // Your feedback is essential and welcome.